“Start with the Classic in Luxury Firm and move away from it only for a clear reason, such as the HD if you are a heavier sleeper, the Rx if back or joint pain makes firm beds hurt, or the Solaire if the two of you want different firmness.”
Choose the build before the model
The eight mattresses ranked here belong to four families. Five are hybrids with coils (Classic, Latex Hybrid, Memory Foam Hybrid, HD and Rx), the Zenhaven is all latex, the Contour5 is all foam and the Solaire runs on air chambers. Settle on the family first and the choice inside it gets short. Saatva also shows an endorsement from the American Chiropractic Association on several model pages, including the Classic, Contour5 and Solaire.
Match the firmness to how you sleep
Saatva rates firmness from 1 (softest) to 10 (firmest). Side sleepers need a surface that lets the shoulder sink in, such as the Classic in Plush Soft, the Rx or the Memory Foam Hybrid. Back sleepers do well on the Classic in Luxury Firm, the Latex Hybrid or the HD. Stomach sleepers need the most lift, which means the Classic in Firm or the firm side of the Zenhaven.
Weight, couples and adjustable bases
Saatva rates most models for 300 lb per sleeper. Above that, the HD (500 lb) and the Solaire (800 lb) are the two built for the load. Couples who wake each other up do best on foam, so look at the Memory Foam Hybrid or the Contour5. If you sleep on an adjustable base, skip the 14.5-inch Classic, which Saatva does not recommend for one; the Zenhaven, Contour5 and Solaire are all approved for adjustable bases.
Trial, delivery and sales
The 365-night home trial refunds a return minus a $99 processing fee, which also applies to an exchange. Adjustable bases cannot be returned. Each mattress is made to order in one of Saatva’s U.S. factories and then delivered and set up in your bedroom, so plan on a wait of a few weeks rather than days. Saatva does not use coupon codes. Its discounts come as sitewide sales applied in the cart, so a sale period is the moment to buy.
Is a Saatva worth its premium over a boxed mattress? For a pillow-top innerspring or a natural latex bed, we think so; if you mainly want a soft foam bed, a boxed mattress gives you that for far less.
Still weighing Saatva against other brands? Our best mattresses ranking puts the Classic up against the rest of the market, and our Beautyrest mattress reviews cover the best-known innerspring alternative.